Real-Life Emotional Support Had a Stronger Link to Less Loneliness Than Social Media Support
In a national survey of U.S. adults, support from people in everyday life was much more strongly tied to lower loneliness than support received through social media.
The short version
- What they foundLow real-life emotional support was strongly linked with greater loneliness.
- What it meansOnline support may not replace support from real-life relationships.
- What we don't know yetThe study cannot show whether support changes cause loneliness changes.
The study at a glance
- Sample size
- 1,512 adults
- Who
- U.S. adults ages 30-70
- Study type
- National survey analysis
The study examined whether emotional support from social media was linked to loneliness in the same way as emotional support in real life.
Researchers analyzed survey responses from 1,512 U.S. adults ages 30 to 70. Participants were recruited in July and August 2023. The analysis used survey weights, a statistical step intended to make the results better reflect the U.S. adult population in that age range.
Loneliness was measured with a questionnaire subscale called perceived social isolation. This asks about a person’s sense of being socially disconnected. The researchers also asked participants about emotional support in real life, using questions adapted from a standard support measure. They then used the same wording to ask about support received through social media.
The researchers divided reported support into four groups, from lowest to highest. They used a statistical method called logistic regression to study links between support and loneliness. The analysis accounted for seven sociodemographic variables, though the abstract does not list them individually.
When the team looked at real-life emotional support by itself, the difference was large. People in the lowest quarter of real-life support had about eight times the odds of loneliness compared with people in the highest quarter. The adjusted odds ratio was 8.14, with a 95% confidence interval from 5.35 to 12.39.
Social-media-based emotional support also showed a link to loneliness when considered on its own, but it was much smaller. People in the lowest quarter of social-media-based support had 45% higher odds of loneliness than those in the highest quarter. The adjusted odds ratio was 1.45, with a confidence interval from 1.05 to 2.00.
The most important comparison came when the researchers put both kinds of support into the same statistical model. Low real-life emotional support remained significantly associated with loneliness. Social-media-based emotional support did not.
That result does not mean social media has no value, or that online connections cannot feel meaningful. It means that, in this one survey, social-media-based emotional support did not have an independent statistical link to loneliness after the researchers accounted for real-life emotional support.
The study was observational and based on participants’ answers at one point in time. Because of that design, it cannot tell which came first. Lower real-life support may be linked with loneliness, but the results cannot prove that low support caused loneliness. It is also possible that loneliness affects how people experience, seek, or report support.
The researchers note that longitudinal studies, which follow people over time, and qualitative studies, which ask people to describe their experiences in detail, could help explain these relationships. Such work would be needed to better understand whether changes in real-life or online support are followed by changes in loneliness.
The news coverage also discussed a separate paper about social media use soon after waking and depression. But the primary study supplied here examines emotional support and loneliness only, not the timing of social media use or depression.
Why it matters
Many people use social platforms to connect, especially when they feel isolated. This study suggests that emotional support from real-life relationships had a much stronger relationship with loneliness in this group of U.S. adults.
What to keep in mind
This was a one-time survey, so it shows association rather than cause and effect. It included U.S. adults ages 30 to 70, and the results may not apply to other groups.
Joi Frontier Health News shares hopeful, credible health information. It is not medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment — talk with a qualified healthcare professional about your situation. If you are in crisis or thinking about self-harm, contact your local emergency or crisis line.
Comments
Comments here come from JoiApp readers.